Pump comparison chart

 

Power Type Primary Advantages Primary Limitations Initial Cost Maintenance Cost
Electric-Solar/DC Power
  • Long useful life.
  • Low maintenance costs.
  • Free energy.
  • Expensive initial cost.
  • Needs to be coupled with water storage.
$$-$$$ $
Electric - AC
  • Continuous power to pump.
  • Low operational costs.
  • Must be within reasonable distance of electric grid.
  • Initial cost of meter and electrical line installation to site can be expensive.
$ $
Air
  • Simple technology.
  • Long life, low maintenance.
  • Free energy.
  • Dependent upon wind.
  • Needs to be coupled with water storage.
$$ $
Gravity
  • Free energy.
  • Inexpensive.
  • Dependable.
  • Low pressure.
  • Not suitable to all locations.
  • Advance planning necessary when installing in new pond.
$$ $
Wind
  • Free energy.
  • Long life.
  • Adapted to remote locations.
  • Dependent upon wind.
  • Needs to be coupled with water storage.
$$ $
Animal
  • Simple, rugged, portable.
  • Use with ponds, streams, shallow wells.
  • Inexpensive.
  • One unit required for every 25 cattle.
  • Will draw water about 20 feet vertically or 200 feet horizontally.
  • Labor intensive maintenance.
$ $$
Water
  • Inexpensive.
  • Free energy.
  • Low maintenance.
  • Requires year-round surface water flow.
  • Limited output.
  • May not work well in winter.
$ $